The subordinate judiciary is an economic pillar that must correct India
Copyright © HT Digital Streams Limit all rights reserved. The subordinate judiciary is the basis of our justice system, but is plagued by vacancies, backlogs and outdated systems. In summary, comprehensive reforms of India’s lower judiciary can help the Indian economy grow faster. Experience from countries as diverse as Singapore and Kenya shows how such an economic boost can be transferred through judicial efficiency. Imagine a small shop owner, Sunita, waited five years for a district court to resolve a simple rental dispute. As a result, she cannot expand her business, which adversely affects her future. Now multiply her story by 45 million, the number of cases that clog India’s district courts. What if these delays are not just inconvenience, but a silent economic bleeding, which drains about 0.5% of India’s GDP annually, or about 1.5 billion £? What if the solution of our ‘first center of justice’ can cause an economic and social transformation? It is not hypothetics; It is urgent realities that India’s legal system and the economic future of our country are facing. Also read: We need legal systems reforms to quickly reconcile the affairs of the subordinate judiciary, which handles 87.5% of India’s affairs, is the basis of our legal system. However, there are 4,859 vacancies in lower courts, a backlog of business and outdated systems that do not utilize the animal. The vision of ‘Citizen First, Dignity First, Justice First’ demands a renewed district judiciary. As shown by global success stories, the effective subordinate courts can increase GDP through their positive impact on the economy, from global success stories of Singapore. However, India’s district courts remain growth brakes. To realize Vikksit Bharat, we must face four critical challenges and seize daring reforms. First, solve the vacancy crisis: With 4,859 of 22,750 judicial posts empty, judges chase 746 matters to the global best practice of 200-300 annually. In Uttar Pradesh, cases often draw for five years, which erode the trust of small businesses and deter entrepreneurship. The World Bank estimates that reducing judicial vacancies can increase from 25% to 15% investment and business optimism. Kenya’s reforms have drawn more foreign investment in productive sectors. There are many good practices that can borrow India to create a system that improves the quality of appointments. Our judicial services, controlled by states, are of uneven quality. We need a judicial service of India on the lines of services such as the Indian Administrative Service and Indian Forest Service that can attract good quality staff for our courts. With the expansion of our Law Universities Network, we have legally qualified human capital for the purpose. The proposed service can standardize recruitment, while respecting the autonomy of the state to ensure fast merit-based rent. It will also be useful for the early promotion of district judges to high dishes, etc. The vision of the e-court prime minister, with AI and digital text scanners to “analyze pending cases and predict future litigations” is a game changer, but fragmented digitization undermines its potential. Thailand’s digital case management reduced delays by 40%, the AI scheduling of Malaysia saved 15% processing time and Estonia’s fully digital courts processed business 60% faster. India must integrate its e-court ecosystem into a united platform that connects the police, forensic and courts, as envisaged by the prime minister. This can contribute to GDP growth by alleviating the business environment. Also read: Open Network courts can make great reforms in the right process third, the three-year practice requirements for district judges are daring the diversity of the sideline: Only 15% of practicing attorneys are women, which limit the candidate pool. South Africa’s competency-based assessments and the UK’s scenario-based tests offer better solutions, which prioritize skills in new legitimate frameworks above rigid years of practice records. Estonia’s technical skilled right selection increased digital case management by 40%, a model that could adjust India to ensure inclusive, competent courts. Fourth, case management must improve: Digital filing hybrid systems along with manual detection exclude small businesses that cannot navigate the complexity. The prime minister’s call for AI-driven analysis and a united platform is transformative, but underutilized. The Singapore’s integrated case management system reduced the processing times by 35%, Brazil’s e-process system reduced backlog by 25% and Ghana’s double shift courts maximized the availability of infrastructure. India’s 7,500 new court halls were able to adopt the model of Ghana, while AI tools could reduce the disposal times. Also read: A judiciary that withholds judicial overreaction can better serve the cause of justice reforms. Digital systems can exclude rural litigants, fast-lane can jeopardize the quality of quality and budget constraints can hinder states. India’s language and educational diversity requires us to avoid a digital separation. Yet global models offer hope. Kenya’s reforms reduced the disposal times of the commercial case from 465 to 346 days, increasing GDP. Singapore’s mediation solves 80% of the disputes at the court stage. Malaysia’s AI instruments increase the legal consistency. A judicial transformation demands synergy for stakeholders. The government must prioritize the modernization of district courts. Power associations must have the champion reform, legal aid groups can offer pre-litigation support and technical firms must provide digital solutions. The economic interests are colossal. Judicial delays are too expensive. The International Monetary Fund suggests that effective courts can add 0.28 percentage points to GDP per capita growth. Sunita’s guard is not just hair loss, it is India. Supported by Articles 233–237 and the vision of the Prime Minister, district courts can serve India as an economic pillar. The question is not whether we can do that. It is whether we will do it. The authors are Secretary General and Research Fellow, Cuts International respectively. Catch all the business news, market news, news reports and latest news updates on Live Mint. Download the Mint News app to get daily market updates. More Topics #msmes #GDP #indian Economy Read Next Story