Skilled Baker Tries to Salvage Greatest Retailer-Bought Pumpkin Pie

As much as this level

Right here’s on hand exclusively to the Substitute Insider Subscribers. Turn out to be an Insider and Delivery Reading Now.
  • I’m a professional Comparing Pumpkin Pies From Walmart, Kroger, Safeway, and Costco.
  • I didn’t like the pumpkin pie from Kroger, but costco’s used to be for certain tasty and my second decision.
  • Safeway’s used to be the specific store-field pumpkin pie becuse of its balance taste and honest structure.

AS A Skilled Baker, I know the preferrred technique to create a solid pumpkin pie at dwelling – butometimes grabbing one from a local grocery is the specific risk.

To gain the specific store-boiling pumpkin pie, the attach four cakes-from costco, safeway, kroger, and walmart-to the test.

There are the quite loads of pies on tell at Most Grocery Stoles within the Fall, so i didn’t call at any of the places I went to and honest Walked in and grabbed the seasons.

Becuses Pumpkin Pies are in total made with a custard submitting, whic comprises Milk and Eggs, The USDA Recommends Conserving. On the costco and safeway i visited, the pumpkin pies were saved in a refrigerated condominium.

At Walmart and Kroger, They Were on Expose at Room Temperature, Which Ability They Likely Luxuriate in Preservatives or Artificial Substances to Invent Shelf-Staunch.

With all of these factors in mind, I JUDGED EACH ONE FOR FLADE AND TEXTURE.

I BOUGHT A 10-Scramble Pumpkin Pie From Walmart.


A Entire Pumpkin Pie From Walmart

Walmart’s pumpkin pie came in an aluminum pan.

Molly Allen

Walmart HAD A HUGE DISPLAY OF PUPKIN Pies Sitting Out at Room Temperature, SO I Grabbed A 10-Scramble One.

The pie came in an aluminum pie for straightforward serving and used to be packaged in a cardboard field.

Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie Had a Immense Texture and Well-Balancing Model.


A Slit of Pumpkin Pie from Walmart on a Sure Plate

I Loved Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie.

Molly Allen

Walmart’s pumpkin pie used to be simple to reduce at room temperature, so it used to be Straight forward to glean a neat sever that didn’t tumble apart.

The crust used to be nice and gentle-weight with a tasty taste, and the submitting had honest structure whereas peaceful being gentle.

The Balance of Flags used to be splendid, because the pie itelf wasn’t too sweet and the pumpkin-spice taste wasn’t overwhelming.

I came at some level of this pie on Expose at room temperature, which supposed that walmart’s pumpkin treates cherish some added ings to create it shelf-accurate.

I BOUGHT AN 8-INCH PUMPKIN PIE FROM KROGER.


A entire pumpkin pie from kroger

KROGER’S PUMPKIN PIE HAD A CRINKLED CRUST.

Molly Allen

KROGER SELLS Pumpkin Pies Underneath the Retailer’s Bakery Original Goodness Trace. Acciting to the Workers Working at Kroger’s Bakery, The Pies are Baked and Frozen Before ARRIVING AT THE STORE.

I bought an 8-hurry pumpkin pie, which used to be packaged in an aluminum pan and a plastic container.

I thought Kroger’s pumpkin pie had a uncommon but solid taste.


A sever of crogen pumpkin pie on a clear pumpkin

Kroger’s pumpkin pie used to be the smallast out of these i attempted.

Molly Allen

Kroger’s pumpkin pie used to be the smallest of the four of the tried, but it sliced ​​beautyfully at room temperature and appeared appealing. Howver, i Couldn’t Take pride in extra than One Bite.

In my take into yarn, the crust used to be lackluster with the muds, and the taste of the submitting used to be overpowering, with an uncommon combination of Spices. I thought it has a slightly man made taste to it as nicely.

Becuses this pie used to be shelf-accurate, i’d wager that a pair of of the preservative system added to the combination Modified the Traditional Pumpkin-Pie I was having a take into yarn for.

I BOUGHT AN 11-INCH Pumpkin Pie From Safeway.


A Entire Pumpkin Pie From Safeway

Safeway’s Pumpkin Pie Had Some Small Air Bubbles on the Surface.

Molly Allen

I inclined to work at Safeway’s Bakery, so i already kew the chain sells pumpkin pies that they willing and frozen and aren baked within the shop.

I had the probability to rob pies with or with which whipped cream, the bot of which were saved in a refrigerated case within the bakery part. Acciting to the designate on the pie, the whipped cream is manufactured from unique on-location from staunch heavy whipping cream.

I Bought an 11-hurry Pumpkin Pie, Which used to be packaged in an aluminum pan and positioned in a plastic container.

I thought safeway’s pumpkin pie used to be deliciously flavored.


A Slit of Safeway's Pumpkin Pie on a Sure Plate

I for certain loved the flavour of Safeway’s Pumpkin Pie.

Molly Allen

By the appeararance of Safeway’s pumpkin pie, I without a doubt would possibly well well it used to be baked by Original within the Retailer. It has an unlimited structure and used to be Straight forward to sever at room temperature.

The crust used to be gentle and flavorful, with a touch of salt that paired nicely with the submitting, which used to be absolutely toothsome. The Balance of the Pumpkin Filling with the Cinnamon and A whole lot of Spices used to be bellow on.

I BOUGHT A 12-Scramble Pumpkin Pie From Costco.


A Entire Pumpkin Pie From Costco

Costco’s pie used to be the fharest of these i attempted.

Molly Allen

You’ll Need A Costco Memberyship to Snatch One in all the Jumbo Pumpkin Pies, which Can Be Stumbled on in a Refrigeled Case within the Bakery Portion.

Come I As asced the Workers on the Bakery, they Told with Costco’s Pumpkin Pies are Baked on the warehouse.

I BOUGHT The 12-hurry Pumpkin Pie, Packaged in An Aluminum Pan and Plastic Container.

Costco’s Pumpkin Pie Used to be Gentle and Fluffy, with a sweeter taste.


Costco Pumpkin-Pie Slit on a Sure Plate

I thought Costco’s Huge pumpkin pie used to be an unlimited low cost.

Molly Allen

The pumpkin pie i got at Costco used to be over 3 pounds, so i knew it would possibly well well In actual fact dish out quite loads of servings. Notably, I came at some level of it no longer easy to glean a neat sever out of the costco pumpkin pie at room temperature, but i had a less complicated time it used to be chilled.

The crust used to be skinny, without Great taste or texture, and the submitting used to be Incredibly fluffy, as against A whole lot of Richer, Denser Pies.

It had a sweeter taste, with notes of vanilla, but it didn’t admire as necessary pumpkin-spice taste because the quite loads of pies did. Even though it tasted honest, I Also Mandatory a piece extra cinnamon.

Safeway’s pumpkin pie used to be my current, but costco’s used to be a shut second.


Four Pumpkin-Pie Slices on Sure Plates with Red "Winner" Text and Arrow Pointing to One From Safeway

Safeway used to be My Winner.

Molly Allen

Nor a baker, a selfmade pie will always be on the high of my list. Composed, of the Suppose One of the most important Retailer-Bought versions of TRIED WERE PRETTY TASTY.

The Textures of Both Costco’s and Safeway’s Pumpkin Pies Were Very Precise. Howver, I Thoughtway’s Used to be the Greatest Retailer-Bought Pumpkin Pie. Its taste gave it an edge over Costco’s current dessert.

Although Costco’s pie used to be for certain honest and an unlimited deal, in contrast with safeway’s, it used to be honest a piece dreary.

Subsequent time i’m in a bustle and favor to rob a pumpkin pie, i’ll head to safeway’s bakery part.

This yarn used to be first and important printed on november 18, 2022, and Most lately as much as this level on September 8, 2025.

Offer link