The AIDS Epidemic’s Toll on the Broadway Theater Neighborhood

Photo: Friedman-Abeles (Drivas, Perkins, Kert, the Boys within the Band); Martha Swope (Frey, Azito, Evans); YouYube (Reiley); Anthony Lewis/Fairfax Media by the expend of Getty Images (Vawter); courtesy of Michael McAssey (Don’t Snort Mama, Blume, Misplaced Web site visitors Checklist); Ron Galella, Ltd./Ron Galella Series by the expend of Getty Images (Carroll); Billy Rose Theatre Division, The Novel York Public Library (Ludlam)

This article used to be featured in One Big Myth, Novel York’s learning advice publication. Compare in right here to procure it nightly.

In the leisurely Eighties and early Nineties, the huge Tower Data on 66th Boulevard and Broadway used to be as cease to a formal assembly dwelling for homosexual males as a chain store could perhaps also procure. Located on the north border of Lincoln Center and accurate all around the avenue from a Barnes & Noble, Tower used to be half of a literal cultural intersection. The store, which used to be typically commence except dreary evening, used to be at cases a brilliant cruising floor for males who liked males who liked opera, dance, song, movies, or theater. That used to be particularly accurate on Tuesdays, when unusual releases came in and guys could perhaps also assert a leisurely-evening hour happily perusing the CDs and perusing the perusers.

Tower used to be also, in these years, a dwelling the place the unpleasant and ever-accelerating crawl with which AIDS used to be ravaging the metropolis’s creative community used to be grimly measurable, man by man. You would possibly want to perhaps presumably also enter the store hopeful and leave feeling punched within the belly. So frequently support then, the foremost be aware of atrocious news used to be the no-news of silence, absence, emptiness — the pleased publicist who without be aware stopped returning your calls; the seat subsequent to you on the ballet, lengthy occupied by the identical passionate subscription holder, that used to be now without be aware vacant. Or the promising actor building an spectacular occupation on Broadway who, without clarification, regarded as if it could perhaps retreat from the scene. I used to be browsing within the store one evening in 1991 when I regarded all over an aisle and saw David Carroll. A gigantic, ultimate-looking musical-theater superstar with an embracingly warm tenor boom, Carroll had earned two Tony nominations, the most latest for Immense Lodge in 1990. He had regarded wholesome at that ceremony; now, a twelve months later, quietly thumbing thru the racks of well-liked forged recordings, he looked drawn, drained, older. He used to be wrapped in a heavy scarf sweater that hung too loosely. His cheekbones forged shadows. You had completely to ogle him to admire what used to be taking place.

Early within the next twelve months, Carroll collapsed and died at a recording session for the Immense Lodge forged album. He used to be 41. The Novel York Times obituary cited a pulmonary embolism as the cause within the support of his loss of life; it didn’t mention that he used to be plagued by complications linked to AIDS. This used to be not habitual; for a few years, “cancer,” “pneumonia,” and “a lengthy sickness” had been ancient in obituaries, assuredly on the ask of of households who wished to steer clear of any implication of AIDS and, assuredly, of homosexuality. Carroll’s loss of life used to be reported by his “companion,” Robert Homma, nonetheless Homma used to be not listed amongst his survivors on the cease of the legend. That be aware used to be essentially reserved for household people, not for enthusiasts, boyfriends, or (in every thing nonetheless the letter of the law) husbands. For years within the paper of file, no homosexual man who died of AIDS-linked diseases used to be survived by one more homosexual man.

More than 40 years after the commence of the epidemic, the rotund numerical scope of the toll AIDS took on the enviornment of theater in Novel York stays complicated to assess. It’s not accurate mistaken loss of life notices that are the enemy of historic precision; it’s the passage of decades. Many of the companions of these males are in actuality long gone, as are many of their household; amongst the residing, some restful tremendously surprised a ways from the stigma connected to AIDS and AIDS-linked diseases. And, obviously, most of these that had been taken by the disease died quietly, in residences or hospitals or hospices, or within the care of the fogeys or siblings who traveled to Novel York to pack up their lives and produce them support to their hometowns. Most of these deaths had been not recorded in newspapers, nonetheless they had been not forgotten. Over the years, folks within the middle of the disaster started preserving their occupy lists of the misplaced — these records had been tiny private acts of anguish and tribute. Giving the dressers, the hairstylists, the assistant stage managers, the junior choreographers, the chorus boys, the makeup artists, the rehearsal pianists, the accountants, and the pit musicians who died of AIDS their lawful dwelling within the narrative of a community that redefined creative activism at a time of siege and vilification requires collective memory. That itself is a priceless and snappy dwindling resource.

Photo: Courtesy of Michael McAssey

The trouble to invent a definitive checklist of names — at least as definitive as all of these keen circumstances allow — began generations ago. One of many folks to strive to take it in hand used to be Peter Neufeld, who started his theater occupation within the 1960s as the assistant firm manager of a mostly forgotten Broadway musical known as Illya Darling; he went on to mosey a a hit theatrical-management firm. After almost 30 years within the industry, he changed into to activism, becoming a member of the staff of the philanthropic group Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS in 1995.

One of Neufeld’s first tasks used to be to attain out to the theater folks he’d labored with and invent a database of these whom BC/EFA could perhaps also rely on to existing up for its advantages, to query the viewers for contributions after displays, to work the phones, or to put together volunteer efforts within Broadway firms. Nonetheless he also persevered engaged on a separate, extra internal most doc he’d begun bigger than a decade earlier: a checklist of all people in theater (and, as it evolved, in other sectors of the humanities) who had died of AIDS-linked diseases. In a desperate time, presumably it used to be his strive to bring advise in self belief to chaos or to strive to flip a disaster that felt plenty of and uncontainable into something that used to be, at least, measurable.

An introductory page acknowledges the checklist’s many sources, from publications (The Advocate, Leisure Weekly, Newsweek) to theater experts to the Actors’ Fund of The United States — and, most tellingly, it cites the “explicit effort … made by the casts and staffs” of loads of lengthy-running Broadway displays, including Cats and The Phantom of the Opera. Those productions had been, all the device in which thru these years, truly permanent ongoing firms staffed with folks that remembered the names of these, both onstage and within the support of the scenes, who came and went, who had been there and then no longer there.

As Neufeld gathered and organized names, he strove to include no topic details about the deceased he had at hand, attempting to show cloak the twelve months of their deaths (“James Raitt, 41, Musical Director/Vocal Arranger, Forever Plaid, ’94,” “Bob Brubach, Actor/Dancer, La Cage, ’88”). When he didn’t occupy tiny print, he merely wrote down no topic he knew: “Son of Joseph Papp, ’91.” Some entries had been apparently accurate reminders to himself: “Trace.” “Jacques.” When Neufeld (who died of Parkinson’s disease in 2015) retired around 2006, he handed alongside the checklist, which had reached an estimated 1,700 names, to Tom Viola, BC/EFA’s then–executive director.

It’s a ways, Viola says as he looks to be over the pages in a convention room of the group’s midtown offices, an unsuitable file: “It used to be an emotional response, as towards a historic response.” What makes the checklist so poignant and strong is that it is, ironically, residing historic previous, nonetheless completely as lengthy as there are folks for whom it’s bigger than accurate a location of professions and ages and dates. “That name honest there, Orrin Reiley,” Viola says, underscoring an entry alongside with his finger. “He used to be within the forged of You Can’t Steal It With You on the Plymouth Theatre with Colleen Dewhurst in 1983.” Dewhurst used to be, at that point, a ancient stage superstar with six Tony nominations and two wins, and Reiley used to be a younger journeyman actor who used to be frequently hired for the chorus or as an understudy. The position Reiley had opposite her used to be his closing Broadway job; he died a little bit over a twelve months later at 38. Dewhurst had liked him and used to be deeply tormented by his loss. She not in an instant spearheaded the formation of Equity Fights AIDS, one among the two organizations that merged into BC/EFA. “His loss of life used to be what moved her to activism,” Viola says.

Support within the day at Tower Data, there used to be a younger, highly opinionated homosexual man who labored the register, an aspiring filmmaker named Kieran Turner. “He used to be considered the bitchiest clerk ever to work there,” says his ultimate friend Christianne Tisdale, an actor who has been half of the Broadway firm of Ghastly since 2019. “Epically abominable. He knew his stuff, and whenever you happen to didn’t, he can be fierce. And he used to be moderately comely, so, obviously, folks would’ve been treasure …” A snappy pantomime of homosexual bedazzlement flickers all over her face. “He used to be a appealing little creature.” His first documentary, Jobriath A.D. (2012), used to be a unhappy and consuming portrait of a 1970s performer who used to be once when compared with David Bowie and is believed to be the foremost fully out glam-rocker; soon after his first two albums, his occupation went up in flames. Jobriath died of AIDS-linked sickness within the Chelsea hotel in 1983, little remembered.

By the time Turner started his subsequent film, he used to be forty eight, and he had chosen an perfect extra complicated retrieval venture — one who, in a capability, used to be intended to carry out what Neufeld’s checklist had begun decades earlier. Titled Ghost Lights: Reclaiming Theater within the Age of AIDS, the film would expose the legend of theater’s devastation and resilience within the face of an existential possibility to the folks that kept it going. “He felt a grand connection with this inhabitants and with this legend,” says Tisdale, who came aboard to occupy the movie. Turner’s passion had grown from the front-of-home jobs he had taken as a younger man working for Broadway’s Shubert Group. Evening after evening, it used to be unimaginable for him to leave out the toll the disease used to be taking on the theater community. “Kieran would read obituaries and back seeing all these deaths within the theater world that had been accurate unique, with all these outlandish causes,” says Tisdale. “So many younger males, nonetheless none of them had been death of AIDS. Kieran used to be treasure, Oh, there could be a legend right here that’s in hazard of being misplaced forever.” Years later, he started compiling his occupy database of names, labeled DEATHS GRID, which changed into the foundational learn for the movie.

In 2016, Turner used to be diagnosed with cancer and needed to lengthen work to commence up chemotherapy. Six years later, as the film used to be underway, his cancer returned. Even as he persevered to source archival topic topic, he used to be frequently in effort that used to be complicated to ignore or veil. Alternatively, Turner came cease to ending Ghost Lights, banking bigger than 150 interviews with theater directors, choreographers, producers, writers, actors, and journalists, many of whom witnessed the foremost 15 years of the disaster, earlier than he died at 56 this previous December.

Turner’s documentary, which is now being overseen by Tisdale and the production firm RadicalMedia, is seeking out funds for completion. Tisdale assuredly feels overwhelmed by the breadth of the legend it’s telling. “Is a thousand a safe estimate for these that died? It’s doubtlessly low,” she says. “Peaceful, that’s the ensemble of Ghastly, death twice a twelve months for two decades. The total hopes and desires that they had, all that their households occupy misplaced. The total communities that had been misplaced, the total work that they had but to total. It’s all long gone.”

On the time of Turner’s loss of life, a handful of interviews remained on his desire checklist. One of many folks he had on the initiating hoped to consult with with, the actor Jonathan Groff, on the initiating changed into down the ask of. Groff used to be restful in grade college when the catastrophe unfolded; he told Turner he had extra questions than solutions. The producers reapproached him and requested if he would take into story serving as, in Tisdale’s words, a roughly on-camera “tour manual … a bridge between generations and a conduit to our viewers.” He agreed. Here’s, presumably, the central mission shared by filmmakers, museum curators, advocates, and activists — to bring a vanished era to life for generations of youthful unique folks, to expose them what it used to be treasure earlier than there’s nobody left who is aware of firsthand.

It’s something Viola thinks about loads. Especially within the spring, when younger dancers on the height of their health, promise, and physical power swarm rehearsal studios for Broadway Bares. Most of them had been not born when the annual profit began 33 years ago. “How cease we attain them?” he wonders. “Can we take them to The Strange Heart? Can we existing them Continue to exist a Plague? We strive to present them a strategy of what we sprang from.” When he displays these dancers Neufeld’s checklist, he says they react “the identical system we’d react to learning about the Vietnam Battle. Some with anguish. Some with, Oh my God, how could perhaps also that happen? And some with, Smartly, that’s attention-grabbing, nonetheless what does it occupy to total with me? You hope it’s a warning, nonetheless it’s essential to to perhaps presumably also’t ask them to soak up that or trace it, not within the event that they didn’t cross despite the indisputable truth that it. That is human nature.”

For over a decade, Neufeld’s checklist sat dormant within the BC/EFA offices. Over time, what had begun as a non-public venture bought the weight of a semi-decent doc — a roll call of the dreary. There used to be completely one copy, kept in a file drawer in case it used to be ever wished. A couple of years ago, it at closing used to be. The Museum of Broadway, then making ready for its opening in 2022, bought involved with Viola, seeking out his back in selecting names to be half of a permanent exhibition that will commemorate AIDS activism in theater and pay tribute to these that died. Viola retrieved Neufeld’s checklist, and to complement it, he changed into to his veteran ultimate friend Michael McAssey, a outdated performer and musical director on Broadway and in Novel York cabaret. Eventually around 1982, McAssey had opened a pocket-size spiral-breeze diary and written LOST FRIENDS on the pinnacle of a page. Below, he started jotting down names — of folks he’d known, performed with, played for. He searched his memory for the services and products he had attended and sung at. The first name he placed on his checklist used to be Bobby Blume, “a nice piano player and songwriter who wished folks to allege his songs on demos. I’d trot to his residence within the West Village and file for him.” When Blume changed into ill and started lacking appointments and rehearsals, most folks hadn’t heard the time interval AIDS. By the time he died, in 1984, all people knew it.

McAssey kept writing — there used to be Greg and John and Scott and John and Tom and Richard and Tory and John and Eddie and Timothy. He added around 125 names over the subsequent five years. Most, nonetheless not all, of the misplaced chums had been victims of AIDS. Every December on World AIDS Day, he posts the names on social media. “Of us are repeatedly announcing, ‘Smartly, that’s morbid,’” McAssey says. “It’s not morbid. I ogle at these names and in assert that they sign me smile. The oldsters I would hold out with on the cabarets and the piano bars within the early days changed into a form of 2d household. We would occupy Thanksgivings together — the folks that couldn’t trot home. These had been folks I laughed with. We had the supreme cases earlier than the horrifying cases.” Even after removing dozens of names, McAssey and Viola restful had well over 1,000 names to present the museum — bigger than could perhaps also match on the exhibition’s memory wall. McAssey has since spent hours there, the performed demonstrate; assuredly he’ll photo a name on the wall and send the image to a household member as a job of allowing them to know that a loved one has not been forgotten. And he restful thinks about the folks whose names aren’t there. “I don’t know how again and again I’ve stared at that thing,” he says. “Indirectly, you accurate occupy to let it trot.”

Photo-collage: From left, top row: Robert Drivas (d. 1986) and Eileen Heckart in rehearsal for And Things That Scoot Bump within the Evening in 1965. Leonard Frey (d. 1988) and Rita Moreno in The Nationwide Health in 1974. Tony Azito (d. 1995), Meryl Streep, and Christopher Lloyd in Gay Pause in 1977. 2nd row: Orrin Reiley (d. 1984) in Seein’ the Light in 1978.Ron Vawter (d. 1994) on the Adelaide Competition Theatre in 1986. Anthony Perkins (d. 1992) in Harold in 1962. Third row: Larry Kert (d. 1991) and Susan Browning in Firm in 1970. Charles Ludlam (d. 1987). Workers of Don’t Snort Mama in 1982. Three died of AIDS-linked diseases. Solid of The Boys within the Band in 1968. Five of the well-liked forged people died of AIDS-linked diseases. Bottom row: Peter Evans (d. 1989) in A Existence within the Theatre in 1977. David Carroll (d. 1992) and Mary Tyler Moore within the support of the scenes at Immense Lodge in 1990. Bobby Blume (d. 1984).

Thank you for subscribing and supporting our journalism.
If you to opt to read in print, it’s essential to to perhaps presumably also procure this text within the April 7, 2025, teach of
Novel York Magazine.

Desire extra reports treasure this one? Subscribe now
to back our journalism and procure unlimited procure entry to to our protection.
If you to opt to read in print, it’s essential to to perhaps presumably also procure this text within the April 7, 2025, teach of
Novel York Magazine.