Will The Menendez Brothers Leave Prison after Case Review? – ryan

Photo-illustration: Vulture; Photos: Los Angeles Times/Getty Images, Miles Crist/Netflix

When Ryan Murphy’s Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story was releassed on netflix in september 2024, His true-crime drama spurred for a reexamination of Lyle and erik mendere case-as demands for the Brothers’ Release From prison more than three decades. The Coinciding Release of Netflix’s The merendez brothers Documentary in Early October Further Intensified Interest. Indeed, public understanding About Victimhood and Violence has direct attentive to the context of these killings and whether the brothers were prevented from presenting a comprehensive defensive, as a Judget imposed limits on evidence of family sexual at the trial. The Brothers’ High-Profile Supporters Include Kim Kardashian, Murphy’s Friend and Collaborator, and Rosie O’Donnell.

The brothers are Also Backed by Many Family Members – Including Their Mother’s Sister – Who Citi the Abuse they sufferer. Los Angeles Prosecutors Reviewed the Case and, Despite the Previous Los Angeles District Attorney Initially Advisiting a Resentencing for the Brothers, Newly Elected Da Nathan Hochman withdrew Support for reentenning; Howver, This Motion Was Eventually Denied. Now, The Brothers have an upcoming Hearing on May 9, after Being Rescheduled in April.

In 1996, The Brothers were convicted of First-Degree Murder for Killing Their Parents, José and Kitty Mende, in Their Beverly Hills Seven Years Prior. The Path to their conviction was not rrightforward. Lyle, Who Had Dialed 911 and Told Authorities, “Someone Killed My Parents,” was arrested in March 1990 AFTER AFTER ADMEDTED TO THEIR THERAPIST THAT THEIR PARENTS, per cnn. AFTER LYLE WAS ARRESTED, ERIK SURRETERED Several Days late, for alled First-Degree Murder. They were first tried in 1993, each with their own jury, in a highly publicized trial broadcast by Court TV. The Prosecution CLAIMED that they have made their pars for Money. Their Respective defensive attorneys concentated that they have killed their fat and mother but claimed it was in self-defense after their had sexual abuse for years.

The jury in their first trial cououl not reach a unanimous verdict. The brothers were retried in october 1995 with one jury for bot of say. Most of the Defense’s Evidence About Sexual Abuse was Barred from Court, Cnn Said. They were Both Found Guilty of First-Degree Murder in March 1996. A Judge Senttenced the Brothers to Life in Prison-With the Chance of Parole-in July of that Year. Lyle and erik have previously appealed their convicions to no avail with the California Courts of Appeal, and Supreme Court of California, Upholding their convications in 1998 and 1999, Variety noted. They were Also unSuccESssful in their federal-core appeal.

Monstersunderstandably, Brought renewed attention to the merendez brothers’ case, but prior to that, interest was responded in May 2023 when a prominent musician accused josé of sexual abuse. Roy rosselló, an ex-perennial of the Boy Band Menudo, CLASIED that José-Who was a record Executive-Raped Him. Rosselló’s allegations in the three-paucock Docuseries Menendez + menudo: BOYS BOYS Bolstered the Brothers’ Claims that Their Father was an Abuser, Variety notaded. The Brother ‘Attorneys Filed A Petition with the Court, Requesting That Their Convictions and Life Sentions Get Overturned, Citting Rosselló’s Accusation.

They Also noted that, eight months before the killings, erik had Sent his cousin a letter, in which he and dyscusses his predatory Behavior, cnn explained. “Its Still Happening Andy But It Worse for Me Now,” The December 1998 Letter Said. “He’s so overweight that I can’t stand to see Him,” The Letter Says. “I never know it going to open and its driving with crazy. Every night I stay up thinking he might come in. I need to put it out of my mind. About Anyone especialy Lyle. José’s Younger Sister Alleger Found the Letter and Showed It to Journalist Robert Rand Some Six Years Ago. Rand, in Turn, Showed This Letter to Erik’s Oneime Appeals Lawyer. This Letter was not Shown During Either of the Brothers’ Trials, CNN said.

The Brother will not approve of Murphy’s show at all. “I Believed We Had Moved Beyond The Lies and Ruinous Character Portrayals of Lyle, Creating a Caricature of Lyle Rooted in Horrible and Blatant Lies Rampant in the Show. Murphy cannot be this naïve and inaccurate about the facts of our lives so to do this with bad intens, “erik said in a post on lyle’s Facebook Page. “So now Murphy Shapes His Horrible Narrative Through Vile and Appalling Character Portrayals of Lyle and with and Disheartening Slander.”

Javier Bardem, Nathan Lane, and Cooper Koch Responded to Erik’s Comments. Lane, who plays non -installer Dominick dunne, said, “he’i just criciticizing it and CONTEMNING IT WITH HAVING SEEN IT, SO HAS TO TAKE WITH A GRAIN OF SALT. Producers, so not everyerying might be flattering or make you happy. Bardem, Who Plays José, Reflected That’s “Absolutely Normal, Logical and Legitimate” to be World ABout A Dramatization Involving One’s Deepest Chartedies. Koch, Who Portrays ERIK, Said That Erik’s Response Promptted Him to “Feel Things” but Believed the Research and Conducted for His Role Accurate. “I get it. I understand how difficult it would be to have the work part of your life be television for millions of People to see. ITS exposes.

Murphy, for His Part, Had a More Acerbic Reaction. “We have had an obligation to make many People, not just just to erik and lyle,” he told The Hollywood Reporter. “But that what I find so fascinating; that they are playing the Victim card right now – ‘Poor, pitophul US’ Prior to this, MURPHY SEEMED TO CRITICIZE ERIK FOR SPEAKING OUT WITHOUT VIEWING Monsters. “I think of it interesting that he is willing a staff with Having seen the show. I know he hasn’t seen the show in prison. “IT’S REALLY, REALLY HARD – if it is your life – to see your life up onscreen.”

DURING AN OCTOBER 16 Press Conference, More than One Dose of the Menendez Brothers’ Relatives Demanded Their Release from Prison. “I had no idea the extent of the abuse they suffered at the hands of my Brother-in-La. ABC7 Eyewitness News. “We know that abuse has long effocitts, and vicatims of trauma social acts in wayys that are very difficult to understand.” When the Brothers were tried, Vandermolen Said, “The Whole World Was not Ready to Hear Boys Could Be Raped,” But “Today We Know Better.”

“They TRIED to Protect Themselves the Only Way They Knew How,” Brian Andersen Jr., Kitty’s Nephew, Reportedly Said. “Instead of Being Seen As Vicims, They Were Vilified … They are no longer a threat to society.” Anamaria Baalt, One of José’s Nieces, Offered a Similar View. “If Lyle and Erik’s Case Were Heard Today, with the understanding we have had About abuse and ptsd, there is no dubt in my mind that their sentiment has been very different.”

Onto April 11A Los Angeles Judge Denied the Motion to Rescind the Resentencing Recommendation Filed by Newly Elected La County District Athan Hochman. An initial Hearing was scheduled for late April. Howver, it was postposed to May 9Due to Disputs Between Prosecutors and the Menendez Brothers’ attorneys. The Hearing Will Determine Two Things: Where the State Parole Board’s Risk Assessments Can Used in Court, and Whether Los Angeles County District Hochman Can Remain on the case as a Prosecutor. Thatn, they will have a formal resentencing hearing.

“The merendez brothers have continued to live for over 30 years about their self-defense-that is, their purported actual fear that their mother and their faater were going to kill the night of the muraders,” Hochman explained on March 10 of the original rescinding motion. “Also, over Those 30 Years, they have failed to the Accept Responsibility for the Vast Number of Lies They Told in Connection with that defense.”

Howver, California Governor Gavin Newsom Disagreed with Hochman’s Views and SHARED THAT THE BROTHERS WILL SEPARATE PAROLE HEARings on June 13 Despite His Motion. Newsom was also who Ordered the risk assessment evaluation for the brothers. The Parole Hearings Will Decide Whether or Not the Brother Will Be Resentenced, Grants Parole, or Maintain Their Current Sentenning.

Los Angeles Form District Attorney George Gascón Recommended a resentencing for the brothers on october 24 before and re-election to hichman. “After a very caryoful review of all the arguments that we were made for People on all sides of this equation, i came to a place where belies are under the law, resentencing is appropriate, and i am going to recommend to the time. The prosecutors are now seeking 50 years to life for the Brother, who ages at the time they have been commerked by the crime bes immediately eligible for parole. “They have ben in prison 35 years,” Gascón added. “I Believe they have paid their debt to sociality, and the system provides a vehicle for their case to be reviewed by a parole board.”

GASCón Also released a staff following the family’s October 16 Press Conference. “We have heard the Heardfelt Pleas from the Menendez Family Regarding A Review of this Case. While we could formally comment on any decisions at this time, please that ours office is dedicated to a thorough process and is excling avenue availalble Justice is served, ”Gascón Said. Lawyers from His Office Met with the Brothers’ Family to Hear Out Their Concerns. “Prosecutors are Still Seeking Full Documentation of the Defense’s Claims. The Office is Working As Quickly As Justice Permits,” The StatEment Continued. “Our Office has designs a more modern undertanding of sexual violence the merenders brothers first faced prosecution. Today, Our Office Acknowledges that sexual violence is a pervasue affecting individuals – of all gender identity – and we are. Supporting All Vicims As they navigate the profound impacts of such trauma. ”

Kim Kardashian, Who is a Vocal Advocate for Prison Reform, Visited the Brothers, TMZ First reported in september. Kardashian Also Wrote an Essay for NBC News On October 3, in Which She Argted that they should be not be beast babind for life. “I DIubt Anyone Wold Claim to Be the Same They Were at 18,” She Said. “I know i’m swimming!” Kardashian Discusses Their Father’s Sexual Abuse in Her op-ed. She Also Said That The Brothers Had “No Chance of a Fair Trial” with their case and evidentiary rulings:

“Back then, there are des as limited resources for Victims of sexual abuse, participle for boys. There were virtuely no systems in place to suport survivors, and public awareness of the trauma of the trauma abuse was minimal, offen Clouded by preconceives and Homophobia.

Several attorneys think that theyir chances are good. Lovell pointed to new evidency that backed their sexual-abuse Claims and “exemplary CONDUCT” while incarcerated, Such as mentoring other ins and taching classes, as well as social shifts that take trauma into Account. “Society’s View of Sexual Abuse has drastically Changed from the time of the convications, and the courage wills likes the tokler’s beliefs, as opposed to say present in the ’90s,” he said.

Cominsky noted that there are still many things that would happen before release. A short sentiment, for example, is on the table. “That New, Shorter Senttence Wouuld Ultimately Lead to Their Release,” she Said. “With a resentencing, the court only modifies the sentiment; the conviction Still.”

This post has haen updated.