My Pee-wee Herman Documentary Almost Broke Me

This article was as soon as featured in One Mountainous Memoir, Contemporary York’s studying recommendation e-newsletter. Take a look at in here to acquire it nightly.

When I methodology somebody to acquire a documentary about them, I write a esteem letter. Within the two decades I’ve been making movies, I’ve written limitless ones — to Siegfried & Roy, to soap-opera stars and reclusive musicians. Every so often I’m appealing to their arrogance, generally their sense that they’ve been wronged. Repeatedly, I pause my letters with the identical sentence: “Have confidence shouldn’t be expected. It desires to be earned.”

For years, my dream documentary discipline was as soon as Paul Reubens. His groundbreaking television series, Pee-wee’s Playhouse, defined a entire know-how of idiosyncratic adolescence like myself. For the interval of my childhood, a Pee-wee pull-string doll dangled above my mattress, and I’d mediate at it each night sooner than falling asleep.

Five years within the past, I started reaching out to Reubens by strategy of varied interlocutors. In my esteem letter, I pitched a mental portrait of an artist. Pee-wee was as soon as a cult icon, nonetheless few contributors knew the leisure about his creator rather than what that they had study within the tabloids. My working out was as soon as that Reubens preferred his privateness, and like most of my documentary topics, he was as soon as an unconventional visionary ripe for reappraisal.

Paul, as I came to know him, in the end sat down with me for 40 hours of on-digicam interviews. We reminisced about his childhood in Florida, his early years as a performance artist, his meteoric rise to stardom. He moreover opened up for the main time about his sexuality and the connection he gave up for his profession. The film I made, Pee-wee As Himself, was as soon as four years within the making, and it nearly broke me. Paul by no methodology totally ceded regulate. He refused to whole a final interview relating to the arrests that destroyed his popularity and held up our manufacturing for lengthy stretches of time. For some time, he stopped talking to me, and I feared the venture would by no methodology be carried out. It’d be Paul’s final non-public act, on the opposite hand, that allowed me to pause telling his narrative. On July 31, 2023, per week sooner than our final interview was as soon as scheduled to happen, I realized alongside with the remainder of the sector that he had died of most cancers. I used to be as soon as blindsided. My childhood hero, the particular person I had spent a entire bunch of hours attending to know, laughing and battling with, had been dying, and I by no methodology had a clue.

Paul had contemplated making a documentary about his lifestyles for years, nonetheless said he didn’t like any of the directors he met with attributable to they had been reluctant to permit his enter. The Safdie brothers, old chums of mine, who had been rumored to be in talks with him to work on a brand unique Pee-wee Herman film, requested him to whisper over with me as an different.

It was as soon as the height of lockdown when we met over Skype. When Reubens logged on, I had an awkward moment of starstruck silence. He had a sweet, almond-formed face, and ought to you squinted, that you would be succesful of maybe also look a semblance of Pee-wee. Nevertheless the particular person I used to be as soon as observing was as soon as nothing like his alter ego. He was as soon as Paul. He sat on a groovy orange sofa in front of a modernist flagstone fire and an expansive Los Angeles see. I complimented him on his dwelling —  presumably the exact-lifestyles inspiration for the playhouse from his adolescence’s show — nonetheless he smirked and confessed, “It’s a characterize from the acquire.” Paul didn’t need me to appear the achieve he in actuality lived. I had been warned he’ll be subtle. There had been a series of reliable fallings out, I used to be as soon as commended. I’d continuously remark to skeptical colleagues, “I’m correct with complex contributors.”

Plus we had been each contented. We had been 30 years aside, and he was as soon as a celebrity, nonetheless as a minimum we had that in odd. Other than Paul by no methodology loved the freedoms I did as a younger contented filmmaker. He had been as out as one would possibly maybe be for the interval of art college and made up our minds to return within the closet to pursue mainstream success. For numerous of his grownup lifestyles, Pee-wee and Paul had been two strictly separate parts of himself. I understood that different as a survival intention for contented men of his know-how, nonetheless for Paul it was as soon as a source of disgrace and insecurity. He was as soon as strongly towards his narrative being interpreted by strategy of a queer lens. “I don’t will fill to be depicted as a contented icon,” he said, “nonetheless I originate fill to near out within the documentary.” I by no methodology regarded as Paul to be closeted, nonetheless he had by no methodology discussed his sexuality publicly, and it was as soon as most enthralling later that I spotted he had potentially said the phrases “I’m contented” out loud gorgeous to a diminutive different of chums. Persuading him to claim so on-digicam, I realized, would possibly maybe be a foremost venture.

We spoke regularly for months   —   generally gorgeous hanging out, other times talking by strategy of the documentary job, and to what extent Paul will probably be ready to book the narrative. The dynamic between a documentarian and a discipline is difficult. The relationships are extra collaborative than contributors would possibly maybe perhaps maybe request attributable to we documentary filmmakers don’t gorgeous need acquire entry to. We invade the lives of private contributors with tools and a crew, and we rob their non-public photos to scan and digitize. We build aside a interrogate to topics to signal start forms that grant us permission to make employ of their lifestyles as the uncooked discipline topic for our work. Paul and I had been bonding, nonetheless we had been moreover working out acquire what we wanted from each other.

He would FaceTime me generally, and I’d continuously gather. No dialog lasted for gorgeous quarter-hour. We would focus on for as a minimum two hours at any time when. I started to informally interview Paul about his lifestyles. He shared videos of early performances and television appearances and the places the achieve imprecise recordings would possibly maybe perhaps maybe exist if he hadn’t preserved them himself. We went by strategy of a list of shut to 100 skill interview topics  —  from his classic-college crush to fellow celebrities. We had been in what would possibly maybe be known as a “honeymoon phase.” One night, stoned and lying on the sofa, I answered Paul’s call. Previously a prolific pothead himself, Paul knew acquire me snigger to the level of tears, and that night he was as soon as in uncommon originate. My boyfriend of two decades, Carl, has seen the tubby arc of those queer relationships that straddle the reliable and the non-public, and he warned me after I hung up the phone: “Inquire of out. You guys fill completely no boundaries, and that can also near serve to chunk you.”

In July 2021, I relocated to Los Angeles to start manufacturing. Paul had invited me in to appear his non-public world. He lived in a mid-century dwelling packed to the brim with archives and collectibles. We would take a seat for meetings at his kitchen desk under the Sputnik chandelier that figured prominently on the location of Pee-wee’s Playhouse. Each and each night at sundown, he meditatively unfold dried corn and seeds around his driveway to entice wildlife. We would take a seat on a bench by his front door, quietly searching at dozens of deer emerge from the surrounding hills. I felt we had turn out to be chums. He gave everybody in his inside of circle carte blanche to be in contact with me, and I scheduled a dozen or so on-digicam interviews. He requested me, though, to let him overview the images, which I’m not conversant in doing. I indulged him attributable to I had promised he would possibly maybe be enthusiastic within the job. That’s when we started butting heads. Paul hated how the main two interviews looked and came shut to nerve-racking reshoots. Then, without my knowledge, he requested the manufacturing dressmaker for images of the interview frames on location.

As a director, I’m ancient to getting my methodology, and so was as soon as Paul. He requested our producer, Emma Tillinger Koskoff, to mediate a dialog about editing. As a condition to his participation within the venture, we had agreed that Paul would fill “foremost consultation” for the interval of the making of the film nonetheless that I’d fill final decrease. The extra we talked, the clearer it turned into to him that for all his early enter, documentaries are in actuality made in postproduction, the achieve he would fill less of a remark. Paul brought up the difficulty when the three of us had been riding to the storage devices the achieve he kept decades’ price of props and artifacts. Picking my phrases in moderation, I explained I planned to show him early cuts of the film to aid in solutions his feedback on the opposite hand it would be months sooner than I can even share the leisure. The dialog mercurial escalated, and Paul raised his narrate. He demanded the final notice to hunt recommendation from the edit room, and I used to be as soon as adamant that I needed to aid my editorial independence. I by no methodology would fill agreed to originate the film if I knew that Paul would possibly maybe be breathing down my neck. He snapped serve and said, “That’s precisely what you signed up for.” We arrived on the automobile car parking zone, and Emma left to permit us to fill it out.

We acquired out and walked for a minute in silence sooner than he said, “You and I fill loads extra in odd than you watched. We’re petrified of the identical thing.” He was as soon as disquieted of dropping regulate of his possess narrative over again, and I used to be as soon as disquieted of dropping regulate of my film.

For three months, I filmed with Paul’s chums. Within the period in-between, Paul refused to location a date for his possess on-digicam interview. I attempted to push aside my increasing alarm that he would possibly maybe perhaps maybe by no methodology be interesting to grunt his narrative in his possess phrases. Then, on my final day of shooting, Paul was as soon as ready to start  —  as lengthy as we didn’t shoot at his dwelling. By that level, I didn’t care. I gorgeous wanted to aid issues transferring and film the interview. I requested for two days to arrange, and we staged a rented mid-century dwelling. We made up our minds the most enthralling methodology for filming would possibly maybe be by strategy of an Interrotron, the instrument invented by the documentary filmmaker Errol Morris to venture the interviewer’s face over the digicam lens. This methodology Paul would possibly maybe be trying in the present day on the viewer exact by strategy of the documentary. I requested my cinematographer, David Jacobson, to attain curtains exact by strategy of the digicam so the correct thing Paul would look within the interview chair was as soon as an image of my face. It was as soon as undoubtedly a like version of our FaceTimes.

The afternoon sooner than Paul’s first day of interviews, I acquired a frantic call. He was as soon as anxious that the backdrop and lighting wouldn’t feel correct, and he wanted to negate one more day perfecting it. I commended Paul that we are able to also reschedule if he wanted to, nonetheless after a lengthy, purposeful pause, I said, “I’m going to house you.”

The following day, Paul was as soon as within the interview chair. He would negate an hour describing his first visual impressions as an child or the colors and patterns of the wallpaper in his childhood bedroom. Nevertheless after I attempted to push the dialog ahead, he squirmed, or made fun of me, or requested for a spoil. Each and each time I’d strive a brand unique interrogate, he’d acknowledge with a sarcastic commentary or a wacky facial expression. Every so often he’d acknowledge a interrogate after which digress into a 30-minute monologue about an classic-college prank. I used to be as soon as increasing enthusiastic nonetheless kept a straight face.

Even with ten days scheduled, I wasn’t definite I can even acquire Paul to let his guard down. He was as soon as on tubby expose  —  slippery, rebellious, shameful, and, in moments of reflection, deeply thoughtful and exact, nonetheless he was as soon as aloof conserving serve. “I’m going to aid about a secrets, and although I don’t, I mean, I will by nature,” he said at one level. “I’m the correct particular person that knows the whole lot about me, I mediate. There’s completely secrets that all of us fill to aid that acquire us honest, that acquire us mysterious.” Now I designate that Paul wasn’t gorgeous fighting me. He was as soon as wrestling with himself about how noteworthy to in actuality share on-digicam.

On the fourth day, after 14 hours of interviews, Paul started talking about his college experiments with fade. He knew I used to be as soon as going to attain a interrogate to him next about his sexuality. He was as soon as fidgeting in his seat, jokingly soliciting for lollipops. At final, he pulled me aside and said, “I don’t know put this.” I said, “You gorgeous remark, ‘I’m contented.’” We laughed. “Okay, ought to you remark so,” he said. Paul sat serve within the chair, and I persevered to attain a interrogate to him pointed questions, which he dodged while talking broadly relating to the notice sexuality. In a roundabout map, I interrupted and requested, “Paul, are you contented?”

“Right here is one thing I’ve by no methodology spoken about ever,” he said. “I’ve spoken about it to a psychologist and a therapist. I’ve talked about it to very, very, very, very shut chums … At Cal Arts, no person didn’t know my sexuality, which was as soon as  —  did I remark it? Did it near out? Homosexual.”

, his body relaxed. For the next hour, he commended me the narrative of his college boyfriend, his first factual esteem, an artist named Man, the devastation that adopted when the connection fell aside. “I used to be as soon as as out as you is also,” he said. “And then I went serve into the closet.” They stayed in touch over the years till Man was as soon as in sad health with AIDS. Their final meeting took voice hours sooner than Man died.

That night after we wrapped, Paul FaceTimed me. I feared he was as soon as calling to rob it all serve, to grunt me that he wouldn’t let me employ the discipline materials we had captured that day. As an different, he commended me he was as soon as relieved.

Despite our breakthrough, Paul was as soon as aloof evasive. Over ten days of filming, he had steadily discussed the arrests. More troubling, he was as soon as conserving out on signing his start, and without that, we didn’t fill the rights to make employ of his interview or archival images or to even grunt his narrative. Emma threatened to shut down the manufacturing, and I stayed up at night jumpy that we are able to also not acquire the wanted final interview. Weeks glided by after which months with Paul and the producers at odds, and the venture was as soon as at a standstill. Each and each time my phone rang, my coronary heart started pounding. Both Paul was as soon as calling me with grievances or Emma was as soon as updating me with tainted recordsdata.

I used to be as soon as serve in Contemporary York furiously working with my editor, Damian Rodriguez, to assemble the 40 hours of interviews I filmed with Paul, and the 1,000 hours of archival images our archivist, Brittan Dunham, had already digitized. The manufacturing was as soon as dropping money, nonetheless I belief if I made it to a rough decrease, I can even convince Paul to proceed. He wanted to know what would possibly maybe be misplaced if the film imploded.

My verbal substitute with Paul had turn out to be nerve-racking and infrequent, and in one of our final conversations, he commended me that I used to be as soon as the correct particular person that can also assign the manufacturing. He warned that if I didn’t, I’d remorse it for the remainder of my lifestyles. I pushed serve: “Paul, you is also at battle with the producers, not me, and most enthralling that you would be succesful of maybe acquire the formula to proceed with the film.”

Five months glided by. Paul and I had stopped talking. When we needed to lay off the postproduction workers, I used to be as soon as devastated. My relationship with Carl was as soon as strained, my properly being suffered, and I didn’t know who would hire me after failing to pause the largest film of my profession. Then, on my birthday, I acquired a textual instruct material from Paul with a Betty Boop fascinating GIF. “Overjoyed Fortieth,” it said. He was as soon as a tall believer in birthdays, and this gesture implied shall we aloof be in correct standing. Early the next morning, I woke to one more textual instruct material from Paul, asking to be in contact. He wanted to appear if there generally is a acknowledge to proceed making the film.

The dedication I as soon as felt nearly about two years within the past to build up Paul’s belief had worn. I used to be as soon as skeptical and hurt, and I used to be as soon as making an strive to switch on with my lifestyles and to start unique initiatives. Nevertheless I known as him attributable to I used to be as soon as scheduled to be in L.A. to shoot a freelance job that week. “I’d desire to show you the main Forty five minutes of the film,” I said. Two days later, we had been in a screening room.

Paul arrived alongside with his assistant, Allison Berry, who had labored with him for nearly about 40 years. I used to be as soon as relieved that she joined attributable to Allison was as soon as forthright alongside with her opinions, and I suspected she had been advocating for Paul to pause the film. Forward of issues went off the rails, I rob into tale confiding to Allison about my struggles with Paul. “I mediate he trusts me,” I said tentatively. “Or per chance he doesn’t, and that’s okay,” she said.

I sat on the serve of Paul and Allison as the rough decrease played. Every so often Paul laughed, nonetheless he requested to pause each ten minutes for a toilet spoil. Each and each spoil grew longer, and I belief Paul was as soon as taking time to absorb the trip of searching at his lifestyles play out onscreen. Paul saw the scene depicting his relationship with Man, illustrated with gleaming, romantic Dapper 8 film, which Paul shot within the slack Seventies.

On the pause of the screening, he smiled. For the past two years, after I presented him with an belief, the most enthralling response I can even acquire was as soon as, “I don’t disagree with that.” I’d remark, “So does that mean you pick with it?” He’d give an explanation for, “That’s a diversified class.” Paul said that within the john, he was as soon as brainstorming what he can also aloof remark to me relating to the film. “I peek ahead to helping you acquire it even higher” was as soon as the response he came up with.

I left L.A. impressed by our meeting and optimistic for the main time in a year. Peaceful, the course to ending Paul’s contract, securing the remainder of his archival discipline topic, and sitting down for that final interview was as soon as some distance from obvious. Issues acquired higher after which they didn’t.

Each and each time I expressed hope for a resolution, we’d fall backward toward the identical battle over editorial regulate. When Paul was as soon as stalling, I belief he was as soon as disquieted to whisper relating to the arrests. I moreover puzzled if he had continuously supposed to rob over the film for the interval of postproduction. Nevertheless it undoubtedly was as soon as futile to figure out his pondering. The venture regarded all nonetheless needless.

Then, apparently out of nowhere, we acquired notice that Paul was as soon as ready to switch ahead. His team requested if we are able to also film his interview in two weeks. I used to be as soon as disquieted that Paul was as soon as ready and that he had signed his start. Forward of the shoot, he known as me. His narrate sounded surprisingly ancient, and he requested me to take a seat down. I can even grunt one thing was as soon as sinful.

“I can even not be ready to remain as enthusiastic as I hoped,” he said. “Nevertheless I know that you’ll acquire the film we discussed.” He persevered, “I’m sorry that I used to be as soon as so emotional these past few years,” and I responded, “I’m sorry if I did issues that upset you.” He said gently, “You didn’t originate the leisure sinful.” Then after a lengthy pause, “I belief you.” I used to be as soon as terrified. The most enthralling thing I can even remark serve was as soon as, “I’ll originate correct by you.”

When I hung up the phone, I felt overwhelmed. I didn’t know what had gorgeous took place, on the opposite hand it was as soon as heavy. The next week, after I used to be as soon as shooting one more freelance job sooner than heading to L.A. to film the interview with Paul, I acquired a textual instruct material from an executive at HBO. “Is this exact?” she wrote, alongside with a screenshot from Pee-wee Herman’s Instagram tale. It said, “Final night we said farewell to Paul Reubens, an iconic American actor, comedian, writer, and producer … Paul bravely and privately fought most cancers for years.”

I felt my legs buckling. In a topic of seconds, my phone exploded with an onslaught of texts. Emma known as me, her narrate quavering, while extra calls rolled in. Then I heard from Paul’s shut friend and publicist, Kelly Bush Novak.

Kelly said she had tried to call me sooner than the solutions broke, nonetheless she couldn’t reach me in time. “Paul recorded one thing for you the night sooner than he died,” she said. A pair of days later, I used to be as soon as in her office paying attention to Paul’s deathbed audio. It was as soon as devastating. Nevertheless there was as soon as no time to grieve. The venture I belief would by no methodology look the sunshine of day now had an ending. That night and the year that adopted, I went into filmmaking mode. Within the edit room, I’d generally balk searching at our exchanges. At one level, I commended Paul, “I don’t mediate we’d be here ought to you didn’t fill a minute bit of belief in me.” He shot serve, “You’ve made one documentary I loved, out of what number of  —  six?” Numerous parts had been revealing in solutions I hadn’t pretty understood within the moment. I attempted to recall any indication he can also need been in sad health. The most enthralling thing that came to solutions was as soon as one thing he said off-handedly: “The main to keeping a secret is to grunt no person.”

The film I made about Paul premiered at Sundance in January. I used to be as soon as aloof offended for the methodology he handled me nonetheless moreover regretful that he wasn’t there. Within the pause, there was as soon as a restrict to how noteworthy Paul would let me in. It has taken me some time to esteem why. Paul spent his adulthood hiding on the serve of an alter ego, and he took a jump of religion to share his inside of lifestyles with me. He had made not probably art about self-acceptance nonetheless couldn’t acquire it for himself. The tragedy, I mediate, is that he was as soon as on his methodology.

The opposite day, I used to be as soon as writing a letter to a brand unique discipline. I used to be as soon as about to reproduction and paste my long-established line — “Have confidence shouldn’t be expected. It has to be earned” — after I had a flashback to one thing Paul as soon as said to me. It was as soon as at a moment when issues had been peaceful between us, and I used to be as soon as explaining how I imagined telling his narrative. “I’m realizing that you’re vogue of making a esteem letter within the originate of a movie for me,” he said. “I don’t disagree with that,” I answered. Now that Paul is long gone, I opinion he was as soon as correct. By my film, I used to be as soon as ready to exact that I cherished him.

Pee-wee As Himself is streaming on Max.

Linked