Skilled Baker Tries to Procure Simplest Store-Offered Pumpkin Pie

Up to this level

Right here’s on hand completely to the Industry Insider Subscribers. Become an Insider and Start up Discovering out Now.
  • I’m a official Evaluating Pumpkin Pies From Walmart, Kroger, Safeway, and Costco.
  • I didn’t fancy the pumpkin pie from Kroger, nonetheless costco’s became once in fact tasty and my second different.
  • Safeway’s became once the one retailer-box pumpkin pie becuse of its balance taste and proper building.

AS A Skilled Baker, I know device a solid pumpkin pie at dwelling – butometimes grabbing one from a neighborhood grocery is the one chance.

To fetch the one retailer-boiling pumpkin pie, the put four cakes-from costco, safeway, kroger, and walmart-to the take a look at.

There are the heaps of pies on cloak at Most Grocery Stoles within the Fall, so i didn’t name at any of the locations I went to and proper Walked in and grabbed the seasons.

Becuses Pumpkin Pies are on the final made with a custard submitting, whic comprises Milk and Eggs, The USDA Recommends Keeping. On the costco and safeway i visited, the pumpkin pies had been kept in a refrigerated pickle.

At Walmart and Kroger, They Were on Show cloak at Room Temperature, Which Methodology They In all probability Get Preservatives or Synthetic Factors to Manufacture Shelf-Stable.

With all of these elements in mind, I JUDGED EACH ONE FOR FLADE AND TEXTURE.

I BOUGHT A 10-Bound Pumpkin Pie From Walmart.


A Total Pumpkin Pie From Walmart

Walmart’s pumpkin pie came in an aluminum pan.

Molly Allen

Walmart HAD A HUGE DISPLAY OF PUPKIN Pies Sitting Out at Room Temperature, SO I Grabbed A 10-Bound One.

The pie came in an aluminum pie for easy serving and became once packaged in a cardboard box.

Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie Had a Immense Texture and Effectively-Balancing Model.


A Gash of Pumpkin Pie from Walmart on a Toddle Plate

I Loved Walmart’s Pumpkin Pie.

Molly Allen

Walmart’s pumpkin pie became once easy to lower at room temperature, so it became once Easy to win a tidy slit that didn’t fall apart.

The crust became once good and gentle-weight with a tasty taste, and the submitting had correct building whereas serene being gentle.

The Steadiness of Flags became once very glorious, as the pie itelf wasn’t too sweet and the pumpkin-spice taste wasn’t overwhelming.

I stumbled on this pie on Show cloak at room temperature, which intended that walmart’s pumpkin treates cherish some added ings to device it shelf-right.

I BOUGHT AN 8-INCH PUMPKIN PIE FROM KROGER.


A entire pumpkin pie from kroger

KROGER’S PUMPKIN PIE HAD A CRINKLED CRUST.

Molly Allen

KROGER SELLS Pumpkin Pies Under the Store’s Bakery New Goodness Label. Acciting to the Workers Working at Kroger’s Bakery, The Pies are Baked and Frozen Earlier than ARRIVING AT THE STORE.

I sold an 8-jog pumpkin pie, which became once packaged in an aluminum pan and a plastic container.

I believed Kroger’s pumpkin pie had a recent nonetheless solid taste.


A slit of crogen pumpkin pie on a transparent pumpkin

Kroger’s pumpkin pie became once the smallast out of these i tried.

Molly Allen

Kroger’s pumpkin pie became once the smallest of the four of the tried, then all all over again it sliced ​​beautyfully at room temperature and regarded attention-grabbing. Howver, i Couldn’t Revel in extra than One Chunk.

In my discover, the crust became once lackluster with the muds, and the taste of the submitting became once overpowering, with an recent aggregate of Spices. I believed it has a comparatively man made taste to it as successfully.

Becuses this pie became once shelf-right, i’d bet that just among the preservative device added to the aggregate Modified the Traditional Pumpkin-Pie I became once procuring for.

I BOUGHT AN 11-INCH Pumpkin Pie From Safeway.


A Total Pumpkin Pie From Safeway

Safeway’s Pumpkin Pie Had Some Puny Air Bubbles on the Ground.

Molly Allen

I outmoded to work at Safeway’s Bakery, so i already kew the chain sells pumpkin pies that they ready and frozen and aren baked within the retailer.

I had the chance to clutch pies with or with which whipped cream, the bot of which had been kept in a refrigerated case within the bakery part. Acciting to the worth on the pie, the whipped cream is made of recent on-assign from proper heavy whipping cream.

I Offered an 11-jog Pumpkin Pie, Which became once packaged in an aluminum pan and positioned in a plastic container.

I believed safeway’s pumpkin pie became once deliciously flavored.


A Gash of Safeway's Pumpkin Pie on a Toddle Plate

I in fact loved the taste of Safeway’s Pumpkin Pie.

Molly Allen

By the appeararance of Safeway’s pumpkin pie, I certainly may per chance perhaps perhaps perhaps it became once baked by New within the Store. It has a huge building and became once Easy to slit at room temperature.

The crust became once gentle and flavorful, with a jog of salt that paired successfully with the submitting, which became once fully savory. The Steadiness of the Pumpkin Filling with the Cinnamon and Other Spices became once space on.

I BOUGHT A 12-Bound Pumpkin Pie From Costco.


A Total Pumpkin Pie From Costco

Costco’s pie became once the fharest of these i tried.

Molly Allen

You’ll Need A Costco Memberyship to Grab Regarded as among the Jumbo Pumpkin Pies, which Can Be Learned in a Refrigeled Case within the Bakery Allotment.

Come I As asced the Workers at the Bakery, they Told with Costco’s Pumpkin Pies are Baked at the warehouse.

I BOUGHT The 12-jog Pumpkin Pie, Packaged in An Aluminum Pan and Plastic Container.

Costco’s Pumpkin Pie Used to be Relaxed and Fluffy, with a sweeter taste.


Costco Pumpkin-Pie Gash on a Toddle Plate

I believed Costco’s Immense pumpkin pie became once a huge good deal.

Molly Allen

The pumpkin pie i purchased at Costco became once over 3 kilos, so i knew it would Indisputably dish out heaps of servings. Severely, I stumbled on it tense to win a tidy slit out of the costco pumpkin pie at room temperature, nonetheless i had an more straightforward time it became once chilled.

The crust became once thin, without Vital taste or texture, and the submitting became once Extremely fluffy, in desire to Other Richer, Denser Pies.

It had a sweeter taste, with notes of vanilla, then all all over again it didn’t absorb as worthy pumpkin-spice taste as the other pies did. Even though it tasted correct, I Also Wanted a exiguous bit extra cinnamon.

Safeway’s pumpkin pie became once my well-liked, nonetheless costco’s became once a terminate second.


Four Pumpkin-Pie Slices on Toddle Plates with Red "Winner" Text and Arrow Pointing to One From Safeway

Safeway became once My Winner.

Molly Allen

Nor a baker, a dwelling made pie will always be at the pinnacle of my list. Nonetheless, of the Assume One of the most Store-Offered variations of TRIED WERE PRETTY TASTY.

The Textures of Both Costco’s and Safeway’s Pumpkin Pies Were Very Magnificent. Howver, I Thoughtway’s Used to be the Simplest Store-Offered Pumpkin Pie. Its taste gave it an edge over Costco’s renowned dessert.

Even though Costco’s pie became once in fact correct and a huge deal, when put next to safeway’s, it became once correct a exiguous bit dreary.

Next time i’m in a wander and have to clutch a pumpkin pie, i’ll head to safeway’s bakery part.

This myth became once before every thing printed on november 18, 2022, and Most as of late as a lot as this level on September 8, 2025.

Provide link